[Development] Deprecating modules with 5.5

[Knoll Lars]

On 18/03/15 08:35, "Bo Thorsen" <bo at vikingsoft.eu> wrote:

>Den 18-03-2015 kl. 08:31 skrev Knoll Lars:
>> On 18/03/15 07:44, "Bo Thorsen" <bo at vikingsoft.eu> wrote:
>>
>>> Den 17-03-2015 kl. 23:45 skrev Thiago Macieira:
>>>> On Tuesday 17 March 2015 17:14:38 Jan Kundrát wrote:
>>>>> On Tuesday, 3 February 2015 08:33:46 CET, Knoll Lars wrote:
>>>>>> * Qt WebKit
>>>>> While I understand the reasons on why you want to remove this one, I
>>>>> think
>>>>> that this goes against the promise of compatibility at [1]:
>>>>>
>>>>> "Qt essentials define the foundation of Qt on all platforms. They are
>>>>> available on all supported development platforms and on the tested
>>>>> target
>>>>> platforms. They will remain source and binary compatible during Qt
>>>>>5."
>>>>>
>>>>> Both "Qt WebKit" and "Qt WebKit Widgets" are listed under Essentials.
>>>>> QtScript and QtDeclarative are listed as Addons, and "could probably
>>>>> go".
>> Yes, they are listed under Essentials, and we’ll need to move them over
>>to
>> add-ons. Unfortunately, we rely on a lot of 3rd party code (ie. WebKit)
>> with the module, and as you probably know there were major changes in
>>the
>> landscape happening there when Google decided to for the whole thing and
>> go their own way.
>>
>> Unfortunately this simply made it impossible for us to continue with Qt
>> WebKit as before. We had to make some hard decisions, and the result was
>> to focus on the new Webengine module, as we didn’t see a way to continue
>> to support WebKit properly.
>>
>>>>> You're of course free to do whatever you want to do -- it's just that
>>>>> the
>>>>> project has promised that this won't happen.
>>>> We promised not to break source or binary compatibility. Where are we
>>>> doing
>>>> that?
>>> Removing classes is as binary incompatible as you can possibly make it.
>> Deprecating an API is different from removing it. Deprecating is about
>> asking people not to use this for new code/projects anymore.
>
>Of course, but you said that it will be removed in 5.6.

From the binary packages only, and only if the migration path is easy and
good enough. So far it seems that at least Qt Script and Qt WebKit might
have to stay around a little longer.

Cheers,
Lars